Page 1 of 1

[SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Classic?

Posted: August 22nd, 2013, 9:55 pm
by fragmer
Hello!

Adding new blocks to Minecraft Classic is something everyone wanted for years, and now it's actually possible, thanks to project ClassiCube, custom servers/clients, and Classic Protocol Extensions.

So -- which block types (either from SMP/CMP or completely original ones) would you like to see added? Please let us know!

-> New Block Types Survey <- (now closed)

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 23rd, 2013, 12:38 am
by fragmer
For example, here are a couple blocks I would like to see added -- tile and magma block.
Image
Image

I made the textures for them already. Of course, you don't actually have to make a texture to make a suggestion -- having a good idea is enough.

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 23rd, 2013, 5:43 am
by Fricksionite
Pink leaves / cherry blossoms

Black / imperial bricks

Magma

Multi-colored tiles, if possible, since we're all choosy on bathrooms

Grill - cross metal sheets. Something like :tnt: pattern (underside) but is black and iron-ish

Nuts and Bolts. A slab-block but has that division in the middle, or possibly a philips screw.

Varied water colors. You don't put clean, blue water in swamps, and some people would like blood.

Bronze. Lighter than log, darker than gold, shinier than wood.

Clear glass

Last and the least, fence blocks / furniture blocks

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 23rd, 2013, 12:05 pm
by Jjb14
In classic,

Different styles of log? Like CMP

Sandstone maybe? Used a lot in CMP and would be handy in classic

I very much so like the idea of bronze

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 23rd, 2013, 4:44 pm
by Arkaunis
Basalt Bricks and cobble from tekkit.

A maroon block as like netherbrick.

I'd love to see a greyish brick style like the brick already there, but with varying sizes.

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 24th, 2013, 12:29 am
by canadacanucks01
Brown wool is an absolute must! I have always hated using some form of wood for my creations that are unfortunate to have brown eyes.

What sort of limits are there for this configuration?

It might be cool to have a sub-menu, where you right click a wool block (red for example) and 3 or 4 options/shades pop up.

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 24th, 2013, 12:01 pm
by badrandsteve
If you guys are thinking about the redstone related stuff like pistons, dispensers etc, then they won't be added. I met the creator AndrewPH, he says that it is too hard and a ton of work, so its an actually 'no' for the redstone stuff.

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 24th, 2013, 12:13 pm
by AndrewPH
badrandsteve wrote:If you guys are thinking about the redstone related stuff like pistons, dispensers etc, then they won't be added. I met the creator AndrewPH, he says that it is too hard and a ton of work, so its an actually 'no' for the redstone stuff.

This fella speaks the truth: Redstone is very difficult to implement. We'd have to rewrite large chunks of the client (and fragmer here would have to rewrite huge chunks of fcraft to support it) and overall it wouldn't be worth it.

canadacanucks01 wrote: What sort of limits are there for this configuration?

It might be cool to have a sub-menu, where you right click a wool block (red for example) and 3 or 4 options/shades pop up.

That sort of thing will most likely not be possible without having a ton of blocks (way more than we want) or rewriting chunks of the block handling code to add metadata (something fragmer has made quite clear he does not want to do with fcraft)

And finally, anything involving shapes other than what's already in Minecraft would require a lot of rewriting of the renderer and the physics, so for the time being, they're a 'no', sadly. I would love fenceposts myself, but non-block models are more trouble than they're worth.

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 24th, 2013, 6:51 pm
by ruggedbear
The selection of reds in Classic is pretty embarrassing. Something maroon that doesn't have TNT scrawled on it would be nice.

I was thinking perhaps something modeled after SMP's Nether Brick:
Image

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 27th, 2013, 3:05 pm
by Mozilra
Maybe doors/Ladders/Torches/More tiles/More bricks/Snow/Pole

What about electronics like a Television just as a deco block, much guests make a television in their first home.

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 27th, 2013, 4:24 pm
by Sanjar Khan
The ability to place halfstep in the upper half + half blocks of everything

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 28th, 2013, 4:19 am
by fragmer
Thanks to everyone who submitted survey responses! We've selected 15 blocks (out of ~100 responses) for the first batch:

Image
  • Cobble slab
  • Rope
  • Smooth sandstone
  • Snow
  • Fire (animated)
  • Light-pink wool
  • Forest-green wool
  • Brown wool
  • Deep-blue wool
  • Turquoise wool
  • Ice
  • Ceramic tile
  • Magma
  • Pillar
  • Crate
  • Stone brick
More blocks will definitely be added, in batches, in the future. We're trying to be selective now, to avoid using up all space on the "B" menu :P

Jonty800 and I just finished implementing and testing these custom blocks about an hour ago. FemtoCraft server and ClassiCube client will be the first two pieces of software to support custom blocks, starting tomorrow. fCraft and 800Craft support is coming a bit later. Charged-Miners and xWoM support could happen (depends on those clients' developers). A bunch of other extensions are in the worlds as well.

Exciting times for Classic! :D

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 28th, 2013, 6:29 am
by Flamewarrior199
Fantastic news, an explosion of creativity should follow with these new blocks! Credit to Scoot, Jonty800, Allie and AndrewPH for their great work.

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 30th, 2013, 1:19 am
by 49ERS
You are the best Jonty800 & Scoot
Can't wait to see these blocks in classic :D

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: August 30th, 2013, 4:07 pm
by Kevinsweijen
And AndrewPH and Allie!

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: February 17th, 2014, 4:13 am
by fragmer
A second round of suggestions is in progress! Suggest your ideas here: http://www.classicube.net/forum/viewpost/QS/latest/

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: February 17th, 2014, 9:44 pm
by Hit-Girl
fragmer wrote:A second round of suggestions is in progress! Suggest your ideas here: http://www.classicube.net/forum/viewpost/QS/latest/
That requires signing up, can we not just suggest here? :P

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: February 18th, 2014, 12:22 pm
by portals
Add portals.
Image

Re: [SURVEY] What blocks would you like to see added to Clas

Posted: February 21st, 2014, 1:20 am
by fragmer
Hit-Girl wrote:
fragmer wrote:A second round of suggestions is in progress! Suggest your ideas here: http://www.classicube.net/forum/viewpost/QS/latest/
That requires signing up, can we not just suggest here? :P
You can suggest here too! I'll count it.