fCraft Forums

Ban Appeal - Pelvicultrasound
when:4/18/2012
Who: pemalite

Reason: grief in Dobby_Ashy's home

I'm not sure what I did wrong, I did mine into dobby's house , but i mined all natural blocks.

I really hope this can be figured out

I'm not quite sure if this was legal, some dirt and stone blocks were removed (Hit_Girl removed some cobblestone).
From the PvP Rules (http://forum.fcraft.net/viewtopic.php?f=28&t=1520):

Hit-Girl wrote:...
- You may not grief any blocks placed by other people in order to get to your opponent. You may, however, tunnel under/through naturally gen'd blocks to get to the person if at all possible.
...

I'm not sure that PvP rules even apply, since dobby_ashy was offline as he says...

Images:
Look at dobby_ashy's post for more accurate images.

Just some screenshots of the grief:
(Large images)

Just outside the back of the house:

Inside, just behind a locked door to get into my mobspawner:

The killing room, part of the mobspawner. Next to a locked door, getting out:

You did actually break cobblestone blocks to get out of the killing room, those cobble blocks were not natural blocks.

Also, Pyro, I surrounded the entrance with the dirt to stop anyone covering it up until this is dealt with.

dobby_ashy wrote:Also, Pyro, I surrounded the entrance with the dirt to stop anyone covering it up until this is dealt with.

Ok, i will edit my post.
Also fix your links, we are lazy :3

I was going to talk to pelvic before hand to get an explanation, I can understand that this is a grey area as some of the blocks were natural.

He also altered some of SurferDude's build also. (I think Ninjacat will provide some information on that, soon.)

Stuff

I give up.

Alright Pelvic.
Lets say you had a small build inside a mountain... If everyone was allowed to tunnel into it... The mountain would look like a beehive with holes and tunnels everywhere.
People should respect other peoples things. Other than chests... Leave their shit alone.

YOU were an OP, you are someone that other players look up to, if they see you setting an example of where it's fine to tunnel and grief someones build, they will all do it.
You are supposed to be responsible and trustworthy, you have proven otherwise, use your common sense!

Alright, because I have little trust in you after all this drama, here is the deal.

You will be unbanned and demoted to Veteran on Freebuild, member on SMP. This is not negotiable.
As for getting your ranks back, don't expect it anytime soon, the staff will discuss that when we think you have proven to be trustworthy and responsible.

Anyway. Appeal accepted with conditions.